Catherine Rowlands
Practice Areas
What They Say
"extremely responsive, good at meeting tight deadlines and excellent at finding solutions to difficult problems."
Chambers & Partners 2011
Recent Key Cases
- Judge quashes wind farm permission in case brought by local authority, English Heritage and the National Trust
In an important decision on the correct approach to development affecting heritage assets, Mrs Justice Lang has struck down the decision of a planning inspector allowing a wind farm within [...]
- Falis Ibrahim v London Borough of Wandsworth [2013] EWCA Civ. 20
David Lintott successfully appeared for the Respondent local authority. The Court of Appeal has dismissed the Appellant’s appeal and held that the Respondent local authority had not acted in breach [...]
- See full text of case
- Re-determination – Material Considerations
Where a planning appeal is quashed by the High Court, it is incapable of ever having had any legal effect upon the rights and duties of the parties. There is, [...]
- Allotment status clarified
The High Court (Chancery Division) has given judgment in a case brought by two allotment holders in which the Court was asked to determine which of two inconsistent powers of sale applied to the [...]
- Trail Riders Fellowship v Peak District National Park Authority [2012] EWHC 3359 (Admin)
The powers of a national park authority to make traffic regulation orders were considered by the High Court (Ouseley J). The authority had made an experimental traffic regulation order, which [...]
- Thurrock Borough Council v West [2012] EWCA Civ 1435
In an important judgment for social landlords, the Court of Appeal has allowed an appeal against an Order dismissing the local authority’s possession claim against a “second successor” who had [...]
- Planning inspector refuses permission for 21 hectares of glasshouses: Economic growth does not trump environmental harm under NPPF
Planning permission refused with partial costs for erection of four industrial sized glasshouses for growing crops in West Sussex following inquiry in which Mary Cook acted for the Almodington Association, [...]
- Solihull Metropolitan Council v Elaine Hickin: Supreme Court 25th July 2012
The Supreme Court has delivered an important judgment which potentially affects all joint council tenants. Where one joint tenant dies and the other no longer resides at the property, does [...]
- R (Clockfair Limited) v Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council and Grosvenor Casinos Limited [2012] EWHC 1857 (Admin)
The High Court has delivered an important judgment in the field of casino licensing. While the judgment has ramifications for licensing practitioners, it has a wider significance for public lawyers [...]
- R(Cranfield-Adams) v LB Richmond upon Thames [2012] EWHC 3334 (Admin)
Judge upholds 2 yr suspension for refusal of housing offer – 19 June 2012 A High Court Judge upheld Richmond’s housing allocation scheme, which gives “zero priority” to rehousing applicants [...]
- R (Siwak) v LB Newham [2012] EWHC 1520 (Admin); [2012] EqLR 670, QBD
COURT REFUSES TO MICROMANAGE EQUALITY IMPACT ASSESSMENT On 1st June 2012 Cranston J handed down judgment in the Administrative Court in the case of R (Siwak) v LB Newham. In [...]
- See full text of case
- R (Hemming and Others) v Westminster City Council - Administrative Court
In a seminal judgment, Mr. Justice Keith has ordered restitution of licence fees charged to sex shops by Westminster City Council. A judicial review of Westminster’s sex licensing fees was [...]
- M v London Borough of Croydon [2012] EWCA Civ 595
The Court of Appeal has given important guidance on the approach to costs when judicial review claims settle before final hearing. In an age assessment claim against the London Borough of Croydon [...]
- See full text of case
- Village Green Inquiry, Nottinghamshire
Anthony Porten QC acted for a consortium of builders in a recent Village Green Inquiry which raises an important point of interest: issue estoppel. Mrs Malcolm applied originally in 2006 [...]
- Store wars in the Supreme Court
In a decision of significance for all planning practitioners, the Supreme Court in Tesco Stores v Dundee City Council [2012] UKSC 13 rejected Tesco’s challenge and determined that the interpretation [...]
- Hertfordshire County Council v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government and Metal and Waste Recycling Ltd
This is an important planning case in the High Court concerning the scope of the doctrine of material change of use by intensification, and the proper interpretation of Part 8 [...]
- See full text of case
- Installation of Cattle Grids and By-Passes within Epping Forest at Wake Road, Cross Roads, Rangers Road and Forest Side
In a decision published on 26 March 2012, the Secretary of State granted permission to the Highway Authority to install four cattle grids in four strategic locations within Epping Forest. [...]
- Shepperton Pinewood’s “Project Pinewood”
Secretary of State’s decision to reject Pinewood, Shepperton’s “Project Pinewood”, a proposal for 1600 dwellings in the Green Belt, providing permanent street-scape for filming and a Screen Crafts Academy. Issues involved [...]
- See full text of case
Latest News Stories
Soho Sex Shops Strike Euro-Blow Against Westminster
24.05.2013
R (Hemming & Others) v Westminster City Council, Court of Appeal, 24th May 2013 A group of sex shop owners has won a major victory in the Court of Appeal [...]
read moreCourt of Appeal dismisses appeal in relation to temporary planning permission.
20.05.2013
On 13 May 2013, the Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal against the decision of Mr Justice Holman that a planning inspector had not erred in refusing to grant temporary [...]
read moreMorag Ellis QC chairs 6th National PEBA Conference
16.05.2013
Morag Ellis QC is to chair the 6th National PEBA Conference on the 17th May 2013 to be held at Hogan Lovells. The conference will focus on how best to [...]
read moreHigh Court considers how evidence seeking to establish precise boundaries using datum points should be assessed in boundary dispute
16.05.2013
Matt Hutchings successfully defends a decision of William Hanson, sitting as an Adjudicator to HM Land Registry in Currey v Fletcher [2013], Chancery Division, 15th May 2013. The Adjudicator produced [...]
read moreSecretary of State confirms Aylesbury Estate Compulsory Purchase Order in Southwark
16.05.2013
A compulsory purchase of land at the Aylesbury Estate in the London Borough of Southwark, to facilitate development pursuant to the Council’s Area Action Plan and a planning permission granted [...]
read moreFlexible tenancies: top tips for drafting tenancy agreements
07.05.2013
Having assisted a number of local authorities and housing associations with the implementation of flexible tenancy schemes. Jon Holbrook offers his top tips for landlords drafting flexible tenancy agreement. Click [...]
read moreNo project-splitting for EIA in Brighton
25.04.2013
In Catt v Brighton and Hove City Council [2013] EWHC 977 (Admin) Mr Justice Lindblom has dismissed claims for judicial review of three planning permissions granted by Brighton and Hove [...]
read moreRevocation of SEP does not necessarily mean that the evidence base is no longer applicable”
18.04.2013
In allowing Bellway Homes (South East) Limited’s appeal for residential development on land at Billingshurst , the Inspector stated “Although the SEP has been revoked, its housing requirement figures are [...]
read moreNew Government Proposals on Judicial Review to Curb Weak Claims
09.04.2013
LEGAL AID ONLY TO BE PAID WHERE PERMISSION GRANTED Chris Grayling, Justice Minister, in a Sunday Telegraph interview on 7th April 2013, has placed the funding of judicial review permission [...]
read moreCourt of Appeal rules on requirements of the law of nuisance, and the effects of a statutory scheme of regulation
05.04.2013
The Court of Appeal, in Barratt Homes v Welsh Water [2013] EWCA Civ 233 last week rejected the Defendant’s contentions the law of nuisance necessarily requires there to be an [...]
read moreR (CN) v Lewisham LBC: Court of Appeal to consider whether Article 8 requires court order to evict homeless applicants
27.03.2013
Mohamed v Manek and Desnousse v Newham LBC establish that a licensor of temporary accommodation, pending inquiries into a homelessness application, does not need a court order to evict the [...]
read morePM announces stop to “soft touch” approach to housing and benefits for immigrants
25.03.2013
The proposed measures announced by the PM during his speech on immigration today include: A requirement for local housing authorities to apply a local residence test under their allocation schemes, [...]
read moreMorag Ellis QC attends enthronement of Archbishop of Canterbury in her role as Commissary General to the Diocese of Canterbury.
21.03.2013
On 21st March 2013 Morag Ellis QC attended the enthronement of Justin Welby as the 105th Archbishop of Canterbury. Morag attended the enthronement in her role as Commissary General to [...]
read moreCornerstone Barristers wins Bronze at the Transform Awards for Best Rebrand in Professional Services
20.03.2013
Last night, Cornerstone Barristers’ excellence in rebranding was honoured at Communicate magazine’s Transform Awards 2013 held at The Brewery, London. Cornerstone won a Bronze award in the category of “Best [...]
read moreAdmin Court decision confirms breadth of discretion when deciding sex establishment licences; and extent of duty to give reasons.
19.03.2013
In a judgment that will be of great assistance to licensing authorities, a judge of the High Court dismissed an application for judicial review against a refusal to grant a [...]
read moreLPA has a broad discretion to exclude specific sites from a Neighbourhood Area
15.03.2013
Daws Hill Neighbourhood Forum v. Wycombe DC, SoSCLG and Taylor Wimpey UK Ltd [2013] UKHC (Admin), Supperstone J. On 13 March 2013 the High Court decided that the discretion conferred [...]
read moreZambrano update
12.03.2013
The latest developments in relation to Zambrano litigation are: • The income support case of Sanneh is to proceed on 11th and 12 March 2013. However no determination is expected at that hearing on the question [...]
read moreTrafalgar flag finds new home
11.03.2013
Morag Ellis QC, sitting as Commissary General of the Diocese of Canterbury, Jess handed down judgment in the case of St Mary the Virgin, Selling. The case was interesting for [...]
read more