Ryan Kohli and Rowan Clapp represent Secretary of State in Portland waste incinerator appeal

07 Oct 2025

Public law & judicial review, Planning & environment

Ryan Kohli and Rowan Clapp appear in the Court of Appeal today on behalf of the Secretary of State, defending a challenge to locally controversial plans to build a waste incinerator on the Isle of Portland in Dorset.

The key issues concern:

  • the standard of reasons to be provided by planning decision makers,
  • the construction of relevant policies of the Waste Plan, and
  • whether the decision maker fully considered whether the proposed development was appropriately located in accordance with the provisions of the Waste Plan.